Courtesy of my talented sister Corinna Nichols, a student of ancient Near Eastern languages (and, in a previous life, of Greek and Latin), I am pleased to present a short poem on the Battle of Actium, a familiar subject to fans of Roman history and anyone who made it at least 15 minutes into I, Claudius:
**
The battle for the Roman world
Came down to boy meets boy meets girl:
Antonius, Caesar’s magister,
Was mired in a love affair
With Cleopatra Philopater
(Who also was his children’s mater).
He picked a very foolish fight--
In truth he wasn’t very bright.
He challenged young Octavian
Agrippa, and his navy and
Then with his queen began a battle
With ships stuffed full of sails and chattel.
Thus the once-triumvirate
Their ships with weapons aristate (1),
Met and clashed in mighty fracas
Rome v. posse comitatus,
Led by M. Vipsan. Agrippa
Naval whiz and valiant skipper. (2)
For Cleo and Marc Antony
There would be no amnesty;
In manner most Shakespearian
(Some would say, ophidian)
They shuffled off their mortal coils
Leaving Rome with all the spoils.
Octavian had won the Nile,
Its grain, its every crocodile;
And though the war was slightly civil
No one raised the smallest cavil
Octavian, in fact of matter
Was made a triple triumphator.
And so that day at Actium
Augustus won imperium.
Like a less depressed Aeneas,
(Devoid of any thought impious)
He gave the world the Pax Romana
In truth, Memento Augustana (2).
For more of the learned Mme. Nichols's work, check out her blog, Of a Number of Things.
**
(1) Bristling. No, I'd never heard it before, either.
(2) Okay, this is awesome.
(3) Author's note: accusative neuter plural, in case you were wondering.
Wednesday, August 13, 2014
Saturday, July 05, 2014
Bruges Welcomes You, Provided You Don't Wear Grey
In the Monty Python song “Finland,” Michael Palin referred
to that luminous and chilly country as “A poor second to Belgium / When go-ing
abroad.” If this is actually true, I suspect Belgium's possession of the city
of Bruges has much to do with its comparative attractiveness. Recently, your humble narrator was
lucky enough to visit this medieval port and UNESCO World Heritage site, in the company of my petite amie and some of the three million
tourists who descend on Bruges each year. I of course enjoyed the city's well-known charms:
its gabled and brightly-painted houses, the narrow canals and the swans that
nest by some of them, the cool green isolation of the Minnewater, the beautiful Church of Our Lady, the looming Belfry
containing Bruges' medieval charter, and the Groeninge Museum, with works by
Van Eyck and Bosch and James Ensor. Somehow I avoided sampling any Belgian
chocolate, a peculiar omission given that every second or third store in Bruges is a
chocolate shop. My gustatory adventures I limited to trying a glass of local lager,
which was palatable enough, and a plate of spaghetti bolognese, which was
filling. The local specialty is moules frites – fried mussels – but I
suspect many tourists choose to dine on Belgian waffles instead.
Bruges's story is a typical one in our post-industrial age,
though the city went through its stages of decline and revival much earlier
than most. It was a medieval cloth-making center whose merchants steadily built
up their capital and connections between the eleventh and thirteenth centuries. By the late medieval era the port had become a leading
destination for ships from Italy and the Hanseatic cities, and by the 1400s its
merchants had acquired so much wealth and influence that, according to Fernand
Braudel, Bruges and London and Venice formed an axis of commercial power
dominating western Europe. Bruges suffered, however, from two geographical
problems: the river connecting it to the North Sea had silted up by the late
Middle Ages, and the city lay within the domain of the Duke of Burgundy, whose
principality fell into civil disorder in the late fifteenth century. Political
turmoil allowed the merchants of nearby Antwerp, which had greater political
stability and a better harbor, to grab Bruges' trade after 1500, just as
northern Europe began to benefit from commerce with the Americas and Africa.
(Braudel, The Perspective of the World: Civilization and Capitalism,
15th-18th Century [Harper and Row, 1984], 99-101, 124,
143-44.)
Local investors tried to turn Bruges into a lace-making
center in the seventeenth century, and lace remains a prized souvenir for tourists (imported though it now is from southeast Asia), but
the economy remained depressed into the 1800s. It was during that era of commodified
nostalgia that European and American travelers discovered Bruges, its medieval
buildings untouched by industrialization, and helped reinvent it as a tourist
destination. Not all foreign sojourners came with good intentions, however.
During the First World War, when Germany occupied Belgium, the German Army impressed laborers from Bruges and
other cities. The German Navy built a U-boat base in Bruges,
presumably because its inland location made it less vulnerable to shore
bombardment, and opened a canal connecting the base to the North Sea. In 1916
the Germans brought the captured Captain Charles Fryatt, whom they had condemned for piracy
after he rammed a U-boat the previous year, to Bruges and shot him. (Larry Zuckerman,
The Rape of Belgium [NYU Press, 2004], 158, 171-72.) During the Second World War the Germans
returned and, as the film The Monuments Men recounts, tried to plunder the
city of some of its artistic treasures. Time and a couple of hundred million tourists
have no doubt effaced most of these memories, but I wouldn't want to venture
into Bruges speaking only German.
**
(Images above are of the Minnewater, with the Sashuis [Guard House] in the distance; the Memling Museum; and the Belfry, a familiar landmark to viewers of the film In Bruges.)
Sunday, June 22, 2014
Beringia and Geopolitics
While in graduate school I learned, via the then-new
H-AMINDIAN mailing list, that Europeans had begun developing the Beringian
theory of Native American origins as early as the sixteenth century. Jose de
Acosta and Daniel Gookin, among others, had posited a land bridge or narrow
strait between Siberia and North America well before Vitus Bering's second
voyage, and had asserted Siberio-Indian kinship based on linguistic similarities and
other evidence. More recently, I was surprised to learn, from Claudio Saunt's
intriguing new book West of the Revolution (W.W. Norton, 2014), that
eighteenth-century Europeans used this hypothesis to advance geopolitical
agendas. In the 1750s the Franciscan Jose Torrubia used “Aztec tradition” and
colonial documents to argue that the Indians of Mexico came from Siberia, and
that very little distance separated that chilly wasteland from the northwest
coast of America. When he learned of Bering's discoveries (which the Russians
had kept under wraps for twenty years), Torrubia wrote a long essay warning
that the
“Muscovites” would shortly move into California if not checked (pp. 52-53). In the
early 1770s, Spanish Ambassador Antonio de Lacy noted that the Russians were
using not only geography but the Beringian hypothesis to promote
colonization: Russia, according to one of Catherine II's advisers, had a clear
claim to North America “because that country was once peopled by Siberians” (73-74).
Such reports exaggerated Russia's intentions. It would take
another quarter-century before Russian traders established a settlement east of
Kodiak Island, and several decades before some built a small trading post in
northern California, on the river that a younger Saunt thought must be the
“Rushin' River” (12). Spanish officials of the 1760s and '70s did not have the
benefit of this hindsight, and their alarm caused them to approve the
colonization of California, with, as Saunt observes, devastating consequences
for Native Californians. That fear of Russian expansion drove Spain's colonial
venture in California is well-established. Saunt's new contribution to the
history of that venture is to note how the Beringian-origins theory changed the
way the Spanish thought about geography: it made Siberia, the putative homeland
of Native Americans (with whom the Spanish were quite familiar), a much more
immanent reality, and helped eliminate the mental distance between Russian
Siberia and Spanish America, just as Bering's discoveries were erasing the
physical distance between them. For all its ivory-tower trappings and
pretenses, sometimes intellectual history has a very immediate impact on
political history.
Sunday, June 15, 2014
What I Learned at the Leiden AIW
Since the 1980s a consortium of European scholars has been
running an annual conference on American Indian Studies, and your Humble
Narrator was fortunate enough to attend the thirty-fifth meeting thereof, held
last month in Leiden, Netherlands. Many Europeans are fascinated with Native
Americans, or at least with stereotyped pop-culture versions of them, and Germany has a thriving “Indian hobbyist” culture, whose adherents dress up
in Indian costumes and learn “real” Indian crafts and dances. The
American Indian Workshop took pains to avoid or to critique this kind of
play-acting and stereotyping. The organizers invited numerous Native scholars,
like keynote speaker Henrietta Mann (Cheyenne and Arapaho Tribal College), to
attend, and made this year's conference themes language and communication.
Linguistics is a specialty of the University of Leiden, and language is a key
determinant of how people really think and live. Language is also much harder
to master than quasi-authentic craft skills, a point made by Avelino Esteban
(Universidad Autonomica de Madrid). Esteban gave a presentation on behalf of
the Honoxease Project, a group of European scholars trying to help preserve the
Cheyenne language, which demonstrated to your narrator that Cheyenne, with its complicated verbs, multiple pitches, and other complexities, is not a
language for the faint of heart.
Approximately one hundred people gave presentations at the
workshop, and your narrator was only able to attend about 15-20 papers and
addresses. From these I learned what I should probably already have known,
which is that Native North Americans approach inter-cultural communication with
different priorities than whites. Ukjese Van Kampen (Athabascan/Tutchone), whom
I first had the pleasure to meet two years ago in Helsinki, noted that one of
the most well-known forms of Indian communication, story-telling, can be hard
for outsiders to follow because story-tellers use characters that they assume
are already familiar to their audience. Judith Burch, curator of a visiting
exhibit on Inuit cloth-making, noted that these stories could take the symbolic
form of woven patterns and images, also potentially difficult for outsiders to
understand. Anne Grob (Univ. of Leipzig), who has studied indigenous peoples in
both New Zealand and Montana, observed that while Crows and Maoris are glad to
discuss their cultures with outside scholars, those scholars must take the time
to build a reciprocal relationship with their informants, and remember that to
Native Americans the process of building and maintaining that relationship is
more important than publishable results. Nadia Clerici (University of Genoa),
in an extensive survey of American tribal websites, argued that modern Indians
can and do make an effort to reach out to non-Indians, and that as part of that
effort they challenge stereotypes of Indians as militaristic or
hyper-spiritual, focusing instead on peace-making, democracy (an important
issue for the Iroquois), women's rights, and sovereignty.*
Apropos of challenging stereotypes, several presenters
proved that, contrary to what many Europeans and white Americans believe,
Native Americans have a well-developed sense of humor. Sonja John (Humboldt
University), in a paper on Lakota cartoonist Marty Two Bulls, argued that
Indians used humor to critique their own society in a non-confrontational way.
Bobby Wilson (Dakota), a member of the comedy group The 1491s, showed in video
clips how he and his colleagues use humor to undermine white stereotypes, such
as the ultra-spiritual Indians of kitsch artwork and the hyper-masculine Indian
men (and uber-feminine Indian women) of romance novels like Lakota Surrender.
Susan Livingston (Univ. of Illinois) analyzed the work of the Cree artist Kent
Monkman, showing how he used humorous and shocking imagery to “re-appropriate”
Indian images from popular artists like George Catlin and Frederic Remington,
and to challenge both racial and sexual power dynamics. Audience members at
John's, Livington's, and Tria Andrews's panel saw connections between humor and
Two-Spirited-ness - the assumption of a cross-gender identity by
some Native American men and women – insofar as comedians and Two-Spirited people both go “against the grain” of their societies and challenge apparently fixed rules and identities. One of those commenters, Henrietta Mann, pointed out that the Cheyennes regarded humor, like language itself, as sacred, and that clowning and joke-making were culturally similar to the practices of the Cheyenne Contraries, whose elaborate subversion of social norms gave them great prestige.
some Native American men and women – insofar as comedians and Two-Spirited people both go “against the grain” of their societies and challenge apparently fixed rules and identities. One of those commenters, Henrietta Mann, pointed out that the Cheyennes regarded humor, like language itself, as sacred, and that clowning and joke-making were culturally similar to the practices of the Cheyenne Contraries, whose elaborate subversion of social norms gave them great prestige.
I should note that the audiences at the panels I attended were much livelier than their counterparts at American conferences; rare was the paper that did not generate at least several questions or comments from the audience. I am not sure of the reason for this, but perhaps it lay in the multi-disciplinary nature of the conference itself, and attendees' assumption that they would necessarily have to reach out to scholars from other nations and disciplines. Perhaps western Europeans are more intellectually assertive than Americans. Or perhaps historians, who dominated the stateside academic conferences I've attended, are just more naturally reticent and passive than cultural-studies scholars, linguists, and anthropologists. I suspect answer #3 is closest to the truth: we historians can be a pretty dreary lot, even when we're liquored up.
* On the matter of sovereignty, Julie Reed (U. of
Tennessee) argued that the post-Removal Cherokees used institutions like prisons, schools, orphanages, insane asylums, and disability
pensions to maintain their national sovereignty. If the nineteenth-century
Cherokees could punish their own criminals or declare them criminally insane,
they wouldn't have to turn them over to white authorities; if they could take
care of their own orphans and disabled persons, they could turn away white
reformers who wanted to do that job themselves.
Labels:
Art,
Conferences,
Southeastern Indians,
Travel
Monday, May 19, 2014
Mound Builders Playtest Update
Your humble narrator recently attempted to play-test Mound Builders, the new solitaire game of Mississippian-era exploration and survival. After two hours of
set-up, re-reading (and re-re-reading) the rules, and slow,
methodical play, I managed to make it into the early Mississippian
era, the game's second epoch. My cultural empire extended deep into
Shawnee and Caddo country, generating regular surpluses of hides and
mica, before enemy war parties – notably the Cherokees, whose
homeland I never managed to incorporate – began battering Cahokia's
palisades.
Then I noticed I'd made it through the
Hopewell era without remembering to trigger the revolts specified on
the game's first set of history cards. I apparently misread a paragraph on page 9,
column two of the rulebook (like you do). Well, so much for being
methodical! And so much for trying to write a legitimate session report. I'll make another attempt to play the game correctly, but
it will have to wait until June, as I'll be traveling and Mound
Builders requires more play area than the average hotel table or
airline tray-back provides.
(The image at right shows the game board at the start of the first [Hopewell] era, shortly before I began to screw everything up. Not sure where I placed the fifth peace-pipe marker; I suspect it's out-of-frame. The mug on the right edge of the board, used to hold chiefdom counters, was one I picked up at the 2012 meeting of the American Society for Ethnohistory.)
Friday, May 09, 2014
Everything's Relaxed and Groovy on Helluland
I've always assumed the relationship between the Norse
colonists of medieval Greenland and Newfoundland and the local Native
American (Indian and Inuit) population was stand-offish at best and violent more often
than not. Alfred Crosby (Ecological Imperialism (1986), 48-52) noted
routine skirmishing between Norsemen and Beothuks on Newfoundland and repeated
Inuit raids on Greenland settlements. Jared Diamond (Collapse (2005))
argued that the Greenlanders' hostility toward the Inuit and their cultural
isolationism helped doom their colonies, since it prevented them from copying
the Inuit Arctic toolkit (parkas, kayaks, toggle harpoons) and learning their
neighbors' survival skills. Something about this story, however, never quite
rang true: the medieval Norse were as much traders as warriors, and it seems
unlikely that their remote Arctic colonies would have survived for more than
four centuries in a state of constant warfare with more numerous neighbors.
Within the last decade, archaeologist Patricia Sutherland, formerly of the
Canadian Museum of Civilization and now of the University of Aberdeen, has
confirmed that the standard account of Norse-Native relations is
flawed, and has usefully complicated the narrative of Norse American
colonization.
In 1999, studying fibers found in an early 14th-century
Dorset-culture (Paleo-Inuit) site on Baffin Island, Sutherland determined that
the remains were yarn woven by Greenland Norse. A follow-up study of artifacts
from four Dorset-culture sites on Baffin Island (or Helluland, as the Norse
called it) and Labrador revealed wooden spindles, whetstones, and tally sticks
of the kind used by Norse traders, and Dorset carvings of what appear to
be Europeans. These led her and a Canadian team to a Dorset village site in
Baffin Island's Tanfield Valley, where they located what is
almost certainly a Norse trading post: a large structure with a stone-lined
drain, a latrine that still stank after centuries, remnants of augur holes, and scraps of fur from black
rats, which apparently accompanied the Norse voyagers. Sutherland has not yet
determined how long the site was occupied, but believes the Norse and
Dorset Inuit conducted a lively commerce, swapping walrus ivory and fox
furs for wooden artifacts and metal.
However poor the Greenland Norse relationship with other Native Americans may
have been, it is now evident that at least one nearby indigenous culture was
more than happy to trade peacefully with them. They had, if you will forgive
the expression, taken a liking to a Viking.
(The National Geographic story on Sutherland's excavation
mentions, incidentally, that medieval Norse mariners made it as far as
Ellesmere Island, where evidence of a Norse shipwreck was found in the late
1970s. Ellesmere Island is NORTH of Baffin Island; its northern shore fronts
the Arctic Ocean. Either the sailors were brave or drunk.)
**
(Image above is of Norse tally stick fragments in the collection of the Canadian Museum of History; original can be found here.)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)








